1 hour 30 minutes
30 minutes
Dessert
Intermediate
Fall, Winter
Sometimes when I go to holiday parties I feel like maybe I should get dressed up, but I always end up changing my mind, wiping my lipstick off, and changing back into my flannel shirt before I leave the house. I’ve discovered a workaround, though, for feeling holiday fancy even when I don’t feel like primping—jam thumbprint cookies. Walking into a room with a tray of these little gems, gleaming, I may as well be Liz Taylor, no matter what shoes I’ve got on.
For as dazzling as they look, they’re deceptively low maintenance if you have jam on hand. I most often see raspberry and apricot jam being used, which are among my favorites, but why stop there? I’ve filled my little thumbprint wells with every jam I can think of, and so far, the shining star is rosehip.
It’s vibrant red, but unlike some other red fruit jams, it’s not cloyingly sweet. It’s got substance, it’s got tang, it’s got texture, it’s something akin to an apple, a cherry tomato, a persimmon, but with the sweetness of stonefruits. This jam, partnered with the mild, buttery, biscuity cookie, is the crowning jewel of any holiday meal. If you can’t make the rosehip jam but love a thumbprint cookie, look around for other wild fruits that you could make a jam out of, or maybe a friend already does and you could trade for a jar. Some of my other favorites are currant, chokecherry, and wild plum.
Rosehip Jam 1 lb. rosehips, after trimming leaves and stems off 2 cups water 1¼ cup granulated sugar ¾ tsp. powdered pectin Juice of one lemon
Cookie Dough
Rosehip Jam This is using either fresh or frozen rosehips. Dried rosehips can be used to make jam, but I’ve not personally done it. Also to be noted, many rosehip jams incorporate oranges, lemons, and apples for flavor, texture, and mostly, for pectin. I do love the flavor of citrus with rosehips, so I’ve added the lemon juice here, but I chose to share this recipe with powdered pectin instead of apples and oranges because I’ve gotten the most consistently jammy texture. While most times, if my jam doesn’t set, I just smile and call it syrup, but for these thumbprint cookies, a syrup won’t do.
Thumbprint Cookies
1 hour 30 minutes
30 minutes
Dessert
Intermediate
Fall, Winter
Sometimes when I go to holiday parties I feel like maybe I should get dressed up, but I always end up changing my mind, wiping my lipstick off, and changing back into my flannel shirt before I leave the house. I’ve discovered a workaround, though, for feeling holiday fancy even when I don’t feel like primping—jam thumbprint cookies. Walking into a room with a tray of these little gems, gleaming, I may as well be Liz Taylor, no matter what shoes I’ve got on.
For as dazzling as they look, they’re deceptively low maintenance if you have jam on hand. I most often see raspberry and apricot jam being used, which are among my favorites, but why stop there? I’ve filled my little thumbprint wells with every jam I can think of, and so far, the shining star is rosehip.
It’s vibrant red, but unlike some other red fruit jams, it’s not cloyingly sweet. It’s got substance, it’s got tang, it’s got texture, it’s something akin to an apple, a cherry tomato, a persimmon, but with the sweetness of stonefruits. This jam, partnered with the mild, buttery, biscuity cookie, is the crowning jewel of any holiday meal. If you can’t make the rosehip jam but love a thumbprint cookie, look around for other wild fruits that you could make a jam out of, or maybe a friend already does and you could trade for a jar. Some of my other favorites are currant, chokecherry, and wild plum.
Rosehip Jam 1 lb. rosehips, after trimming leaves and stems off 2 cups water 1¼ cup granulated sugar ¾ tsp. powdered pectin Juice of one lemon
Cookie Dough
Rosehip Jam This is using either fresh or frozen rosehips. Dried rosehips can be used to make jam, but I’ve not personally done it. Also to be noted, many rosehip jams incorporate oranges, lemons, and apples for flavor, texture, and mostly, for pectin. I do love the flavor of citrus with rosehips, so I’ve added the lemon juice here, but I chose to share this recipe with powdered pectin instead of apples and oranges because I’ve gotten the most consistently jammy texture. While most times, if my jam doesn’t set, I just smile and call it syrup, but for these thumbprint cookies, a syrup won’t do.
Thumbprint Cookies